Best Baby Teething Toys 2026: Three Shapes for Sore Gums
Compare baby teething toys from Comotomo, Baby Banana and Manhattan Toy, including cleaning, shapes and grasping differences to help families choose today.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Prices and availability are accurate as of the time of publication and are subject to change.
The Comotomo Silicone Teether is our best overall baby teething toy for families who want a one-piece option with multiple gripping and chewing points. The Baby Banana adds brushing practice, while the Manhattan Toy Winkel combines grasping loops with a rattle. We compared documented features and care instructions rather than conducting hands-on tests.
| Product | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Comotomo Silicone Teether | Best overall | View |
| Baby Banana Toothbrush-Teether | Best for brushing practice | View |
| Manhattan Toy Winkel | Best for grasping play | View |
Best baby teething toys compared
Comotomo Silicone Teether
Comotomo Silicone Teether
Comotomo earns our overall pick for its straightforward one-piece design and four finger-shaped prongs, which offer several places for a baby to explore with their mouth. The food-grade silicone teether has no moving parts, and the maker recommends it from three months. It is dishwasher safe on the top rack and can also be cleaned according to the manufacturer's sterilizing instructions, so families have more than one cleaning option. Choose it if you want a dedicated teether with an easy-to-grasp shape rather than a brush or rattle. The tradeoff is that it offers neither Baby Banana's brush-shaped bristles nor the Winkel's sound and large loops. As with any teether, supervise use, check it for damage and follow the supplied care directions.
Pros
- One-piece food-grade silicone has four finger-shaped prongs
- Can be cleaned on the top rack of the dishwasher
Cons
- Does not have a rattle for sound during play
- Lacks brush-shaped bristles for introducing toothbrushing
Baby Banana Toothbrush-Teether
Baby Banana Toothbrush-Teether
The Baby Banana is the strongest choice for families who want a teether that also introduces the feel of a toothbrush. Its soft silicone bristles are intended to massage gums, and the banana peel handles give little hands a place to grip. The listing specifies food-grade silicone, an age range of three to 18 months and dishwasher-safe cleaning. Unlike Comotomo's finger-shaped prongs, its main feature is the brush-shaped end. The tradeoff is that mouthing a training brush does not replace an adult cleaning a child's teeth. It is also less of an all-around play object than the Winkel, which has a rattle and multiple loops. Pick it for oral-care familiarity rather than sound or several prongs to explore.
Pros
- Soft silicone bristles introduce a brush-like texture
- Peel handles provide a grasp and the brush is dishwasher safe
Cons
- Does not replace an adult brushing the child's teeth
- No built-in rattle or large grasping loops like the Winkel
Manhattan Toy Winkel
Manhattan Toy Winkel
The classic Winkel stands out for play as much as chewing. Soft, continuous polyurethane loops surround a central cube containing a quiet rattle, giving a baby more than one place to grasp and an audible response to movement. Manhattan Toy lists the model for newborns and up, with dimensions of roughly 5 by 4 by 3.5 inches, and says it can be refrigerated. It earns the grasping badge for families who want one object for both early hand exploration and mouthing. Its cleaning rules are the compromise: surface-wash it, then wipe away soap, and do not submerge it. The open loops also occupy more bag space than a flat brush. This listing is for the classic model, not the separately recalled Colorburst lots discussed below.
Pros
- Flexible loops offer several grasping points around a central rattle
- Newborn-rated classic model can be cooled in a refrigerator
Cons
- Surface cleaning is required because it cannot be submerged
- The three-dimensional loop shape takes more bag space than a slim brush
How to choose and use a teether
Think about the job first. Comotomo offers four prongs in a one-piece shape, the Banana offers brush-like bristles, and the Winkel gives more to look at and grasp. A toy suitable from birth is not necessarily the one a three-month-old will prefer: size, grip and texture all affect whether a child can comfortably hold it. Follow the age guidance on the exact item rather than treating these products as interchangeable.
Cleaning is also part of the choice, especially if the toy will travel between home and a changing bag. The Banana and Comotomo can go in the dishwasher, while the Winkel must not be immersed. Make space for the correct routine and allow the toy to dry before storing it. If another adult cares for your baby, share the instructions so everyone uses the same method.
Inspect teethers before every use and remove one if it is damaged. Use them with adult supervision, follow the maker's cleaning directions and avoid attaching a teether to a cord around a baby's neck. The FDA recommends a firm rubber teether that is not liquid-filled and advises against freezing it because excessive hardness can hurt gums. Ask a healthcare professional if discomfort seems severe or you have questions about symptoms or dental care.
The Winkel compared here is the classic 200930. In 2017, certain lots of a different Winkel Colorburst model were recalled because tubes could break. If receiving a secondhand Winkel, check its model and lot against the manufacturer's recall information and do not use a recalled item.
Frequently asked questions
Can I put these teethers in the freezer?
The FDA advises against freezing a teether because a very hard object can hurt gums. Manhattan Toy allows refrigeration of the Winkel, and Comotomo also describes cooling its teether, but follow the instructions for the exact product and avoid freezing. Supervise your child and consult a healthcare professional if you need individual advice.
Which one is easiest to clean?
The Baby Banana listing says it is dishwasher safe, and Comotomo says its one-piece teether can go on the dishwasher's top rack. Either may suit a family that relies on a dishwasher. The Winkel must be surface-washed and not submerged, so cleaning between its loops requires attention. Follow each product's supplied care instructions.
Does a teething toothbrush replace normal brushing?
No. The Baby Banana can introduce a soft bristle texture, but a child chewing it is not the same as an adult cleaning teeth. Ask your dentist or healthcare professional for age-appropriate brushing and toothpaste advice, and supervise use. Choose Comotomo or Winkel if a one-piece teether or grasping play is the main reason for buying.
Prices and availability are accurate as of publication and may change.